FI-PI-LI, Tuscany at a crossroads: young people and the service sector demand more public transport, while the third lane fails to convince
m.nardini
Tue, 12/02/2025 - 15:08
Transport in Tuscany is at a turning point. This is what emerges from the SAMPLE project, carried out by the Institute of Management of the Sant Anna School of Advanced Studies and the North-West Tuscany Chamber of Commerce, which collected 1,995 responses from citizens and 134 from businesses to assess perceptions, preferences and priorities regarding the future of one of the strategic hubs for transport in the Tuscany region: the Florence-Pisa-Livorno motorway. The study evaluated three possible scenarios: Business as Usual, which involves maintaining the infrastructure as it is, with minimal interve Road, which involves building a third lane and expanding the capacity of the mo and Contextual, which focuses on public transport, cycling and intermodality. The study reveals an unequivocal verdict: the status quo is by far the least popular scenario. Maintaining the current situation is met with the most outright rejection by citizens and businesses, undermined above all by serious concerns about road safety, which reduce its acceptability by 14%. The clearest data concerns young people: those under 40 with a high level of education (degree or higher) show marked enthusiasm for the Contextual Scenario (public transport, cycling and intermodality). For them, the acceptability of the scenario reaches around 70%. This preference is not only based on the present, but also on the future mobility of the Tuscany region: more sustainable, safer and more connected. The position of middle-aged adults with lower educational qualifications is different, as they favour the Road Scenario (construction of the third lane), which in this case has an acceptability rating of 66%. However, as the report points out, investing in the third lane would involve long timescales, high costs and significant environmental impacts, with no possibility of future rethinking. This rigidity contrasts with the modular and scalable approach of the Contextual scenario. On the business side, the analysis highlights differences linked to different priorities that reflect sector-specific characteristics: 43.9% of manufacturers prefer the road solution, while commerce (46.15%), services (38%), education and healthcare (45.5%) favour enhanced public mobility. Size also matters: the road-based approach grows with the size of the business (from 33.3% of micro-businesses to 62.5% of large businesses). The project s advanced statistical analyses confirm a key finding: the acceptability of the scenarios is driven by citizens behavioural habits. Those who habitually use cars are more inclined towards the Road scenario, while those who use bicycles or public transport are the main supporters of the Contextual scenario.The picture that emerges is clear: Tuscany must decide which economic development model it wants to pursue. ‘We promoted this study,’ emphasises Valter Tamburini, President of the North-West Tuscany Chamber of Commerce, with a specific objective: to give a voice to businesses and provide politicians with data-based decision-making tools, overcoming the logic of feelings. The verdict is unequivocal: immobility is rejected without appeal. Citizens and businesses demand safety and efficiency, but with different emphases: while industry favours road improvements, the service sector and young people call for a shift towards intermodality. The real challenge today is not to choose sides, but to manage this complexity with a long-term vision that ensures the competitiveness of our entire economic system. ‘Focusing on sustainable mobility solutions has broader potential implications: an efficient transport system attracts talent and generates a virtuous circle between training, business and innovation,’ says Professor Francesco Rizzi of the Sant Anna School, who led the study with the support of his research team composed of researchers Francesco Ghezzi and Giovanni Gesiot.Following the demand of younger generations and sectors with higher added value means investing in a more efficient, integrated and sustainable public system. Continuing on the path of traditional infrastructure expansion, on the other hand, entails high risks, irreversible costs and unevenly distributed benefits. The choice is not only technical: it is strategic, social and political.
Inserisci negli avvisi in Homepage
Spento
Data pubblicazione
Tue, 12/02/2025 - 14:00
Soggetto
Istitute of Management
Immagini
Full Size Version of Image
Studio Fi-pi-li.jpeg
Full Size Version of Image
Studio Fi-Pi-Li_Giani.jpg
Full Size Version of Image
Studio Fi-pi-li_intervento Rizzi.jpg
Full Size Version of Image
Studio Fi-Pi-Li (2).jpeg
Full Size Version of Image
Studio Fi-Pi-Li 2.jpeg
Full Size Version of Image
Fi-pi-li_ presentaazione studio Sant anna.jpg
Titolo card
FI-PI-LI, Tuscany at a crossroads: young people and the service sector demand more public transport, while the third lane fails to convince
Sunday 7 December 2025
Sant’Anna - 5 days ago
FI-PI-LI, la Toscana davanti a un bivio: giovani e terziario chiedono più mobilità pubblica, mentre la terza corsia non convince
Methods Mondays: Designing and Integrating a Sequential Mixed Methods Study: A Practical Overview
- Queen’sSelezione per la stipula di un contratto di ricerca di durata biennale ai sensi dell’articolo 22 della legge 240/2010 - PHYS-03/A - Fisica sperimentale della materia e applicazioni -
- Sant’AnnaTreasured ‘third spaces’ on campus help students contemplate, connect and find community
- PrincetonMayo Clinic s Erin Sexton named University of Minnesota s vice president for government and community relations
- MMUCooperazione giudiziaria tra Italia e Paesi africani: terminati due workshops in Gabon e Ciad
- Sant’AnnaDHS Sec. Kristi Noem claimed 50% of visas in Minnesota are fraudulent. But is that claim accurate?
- MMU
‘Terms of Respect’: Eisgruber’s book is opening new avenues to share what colleges get right on free speech and academic inquiry
- Princeton
Beijing Foreign Studies Univ MSc International Bu MBA Master s - QS International Trade Ranking - Masters and MBA 2026
- topuniversitiesLa vela italiana lancia la prima valutazione del ciclo di vita di un evento velico: un nuovo standard globale per la sostenibilità grazie al progetto di Federazione Italiana di Vela (FIV) e la Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna
- Sant’AnnaRegenerating the future: Western empowers entrepreneurs to build businesses that restore
- Western OntarioForschungskolleg vernetzt Geistes- und Sozialwissenschaften der UA Ruhr international
- Duisburg-EssenResearch College Connects Humanities and Social Sciences at the UA Ruhr Internationally
- Duisburg-EssenInternational community convenes in Pisa to advance coordinated reform in publishing and research assessment
- LeidenProceeds from Ameland children’s book support new research into the microbiota–gut–brain axis
- LeidenBah Humbug! Young actors gear-up to bring Dicken’s ghosts to life with retelling of A Christmas Carol at Rockingham Castle
- NorthamptonCapio Robotics, Progetto PoC della Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, selezionato per il programma FoodTech Incubator
- Sant’AnnaL’azienda spin-off della Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna ABzero al Drone International Symposium
- Sant’AnnaUConn School of Social Work Strengthens Supervisory Training with Advanced Certificate Program
- ConnecticutÉcole Nationale des Travaux Publiques de LÉtat (ENTPE) - QS Sustainability Ranking 2026
- topuniversities Barcelona
Copenhagen
Gordon
Aberdeen
acenet
Agricultural Sciences
Alabama
Arizona
Autonomous
Bath
Bergen
Bern
Bloomington
Boston
Bozen-Bolzano
Brandeis
Buffalo
Calgary
Cambridge
Central European
Charité
Chester
Colorado Boulder
Connecticut
Copenhagen
Duisburg-Essen
Duke
Dundee
École
Eindhoven
Emory
Estadual de Campinas
Federal do Rio de Janeiro
Florida
Frankfurt am Main
Galway
Geneva
Goethe
Groningen
Harvard
Hawai’i at Mānoa
Hong Kong
Hongkong
Imperial
James Cook
Keele
Kingston
KTH
Laval
Leiden
Liège
Liverpool
Lomonosov Moscow
Luxembourg
Macquarie
Mancunion
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
MMU
Montreal
Nacional de Colombia
Newcastle
Northampton
Nuremberg
Ohio
Ottawa
Oxford
Paris-Sud
Princeton
Purdue
qswownews
Quaid-i-Azam
Queensland
Queen’s
Radboud
Riverside
Ruhr
Rush
Rutgers
RWTH Aachen
Santa Barbara
Santa Cruz
Sant’Anna
São Paulo
Sciences Po
Scuola
SOAS
South Australia
South Florida
Southampton
St-andrews
St. Louis
Stanford
Stirling
Stockholm
Stony Brook
Stuttgart
Surrey
Sussex
SUU
Swansea
Sydney
Syracuse
Texas
Texas A&M
Texas at Dallas
Tokyo
topuniversities
Trento
Tufts
Ulm
USnews/Education
Utah
Utrecht
Wageningen
Waikato
Warwick
Waseda
Washington
Western Australia
Western Ontario
Wilhelms-University Munster
William & Mary
Wollongong
Würzburg
Yale
Yeshiva
⁞
Copenhagen
Gordon
Aberdeen
acenet
Agricultural Sciences
Alabama
Arizona
Autonomous
Bath
Bergen
Bern
Bloomington
Boston
Bozen-Bolzano
Brandeis
Buffalo
Calgary
Cambridge
Central European
Charité
Chester
Colorado Boulder
Connecticut
Copenhagen
Duisburg-Essen
Duke
Dundee
École
Eindhoven
Emory
Estadual de Campinas
Federal do Rio de Janeiro
Florida
Frankfurt am Main
Galway
Geneva
Goethe
Groningen
Harvard
Hawai’i at Mānoa
Hong Kong
Hongkong
Imperial
James Cook
Keele
Kingston
KTH
Laval
Leiden
Liège
Liverpool
Lomonosov Moscow
Luxembourg
Macquarie
Mancunion
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
MMU
Montreal
Nacional de Colombia
Newcastle
Northampton
Nuremberg
Ohio
Ottawa
Oxford
Paris-Sud
Princeton
Purdue
qswownews
Quaid-i-Azam
Queensland
Queen’s
Radboud
Riverside
Ruhr
Rush
Rutgers
RWTH Aachen
Santa Barbara
Santa Cruz
Sant’Anna
São Paulo
Sciences Po
Scuola
SOAS
South Australia
South Florida
Southampton
St-andrews
St. Louis
Stanford
Stirling
Stockholm
Stony Brook
Stuttgart
Surrey
Sussex
SUU
Swansea
Sydney
Syracuse
Texas
Texas A&M
Texas at Dallas
Tokyo
topuniversities
Trento
Tufts
Ulm
USnews/Education
Utah
Utrecht
Wageningen
Waikato
Warwick
Waseda
Washington
Western Australia
Western Ontario
Wilhelms-University Munster
William & Mary
Wollongong
Würzburg
Yale
Yeshiva